Levels: Primary, Middle, High, Other
| Name | Level |
|---|---|
| Alger B. Wilkins High School | High |
| Howard Learning Academy | Middle |
| Ramsey Street High | High |
Levels: Primary, Middle, High, Other
Levels: Elementary School, Secondary School, Other - mixed grades
| Name | Level |
|---|---|
| Bal-Perazim Christian Academy | Mixed Grades |
| Cornerstone Christian Academy | Mixed Grades |
| Fayetteville Academy | Mixed Grades |
| First Impressions Academy | Elementary |
| Greater Fayetteville Adventist | Mixed Grades |
| Liberty Christian Academy | Mixed Grades |
| New Life Christian Academy | Mixed Grades |
| Northview Baptist Academy | Mixed Grades |
| Renaissance Classical Christian Academy | Mixed Grades |
| St. Ann Catholic School | Elementary |
| St. Patrick Catholic School | Elementary |
| Village Christian Academy | Mixed Grades |
Levels: Elementary School, Secondary School, Other - mixed grades